Datapulted

Data Use, Technology, and Educational Leadership

Could the public nature of Twitter HINDER professional learning?

http://learntelau.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/pln-diag-couros.png?w=530

Couros, A. (2006). Examining the open movement: Possibilities and implications for education. PhD thesis, University of Regina, Canada. See p.177 [via http://goo.gl/nW7zi%5D

I’ve been conducting a study about school administrators’ experiences in using Twitter. Analyses are still in the preliminary stages. I have enough trend to raise some questions for debate and exploration, but not to stand as “truth.” One key such question is whether the pubic nature of Twitter could actually hinder professional learning (i.e., the “power” of personal learning networks).

This morning, I came across Carol Skyring’s blog and its advice on developing one’s personal learning network. It suggests that Web 2.0 technologies offer educators all sorts of new (and potentially powerful ways) to collaborate and support each other around issues affecting their work. One of the questions that I’m beginning to examine is whether the picture ought to be made more complicated. What if the potential to be observed (by bosses, colleagues, strangers, or whoever) affects what one says and does online? More specifically, what if the public nature of Twitter means that there are “safe” topics or interactions — wouldn’t that limit what a PLN did (or didn’t) do for you? First I’ll give a sampler of what I’m finding in my study, then I’ll name some findings from other research that help provide some additional background to these questions.

Preliminary interview findings. Overwhelmingly, the administrators I’ve interviewed feel that PLNs (and Twitter) hold power to benefit their practices. I’ve also found, though, that the public nature of Twitter held weight in their thinking. For example, many spoke positively about the importance of managing one’s “digital footprint” and “promoting a professional identity.” This was described not only as part of contemporary life, but also something we needed to teach kids about. Others talked about ed admin “rock stars” on Twitter, about growing one’s audience, and about keeping PLN-related Twitter accounts separate from personal or school accounts.

Could this influence the topics that people actually Tweet (or interact) about? So far, I’ve only analyzed a small share of the Tweets collected, but the answer is “maybe.” To date, the most common tweet topic (27% of tweets) among my sample of administrators were related to technology. Examples might be stuff related to Web 2.0, iPads in the classroom, or personal productivity tools. Next up at 23% were tweets about instructional issues or schooling (e.g., common core standards, lesson ideas). Lagging behind in 3rd place (11%) are tweets that might be considered to be about leadership topics. These included beliefs about good leadership or links to articles about leadership. This is something I’ll keep an eye on as analysis progresses.

Presidio-modelo2

Presidio-Modelo, via wikipedia

This idea isn’t new. Some scholars describe this terms of “impression management.” For example, Orlikowski (1996) reports how increased visibility afforded by one information system resulted workers self-censoring what they shared, working to promote a good image, and changing how they began to collaborate using technology. More recently, Marwick and boyd (2010) talk about the work that Twitter users put into building and responding to their “imagined audiences.” And an oldie but goodie (made famous by Foucault) is the idea of the panopticon: a jail that needs few jailers (if any), because the inmates have only the sense of being under surveillance. These are examples of readings, additional suggestions are welcome!

If trends hold up… The conclusion wouldn’t be that PLNs on Twitter don’t exist, but rather that they aren’t all powerful. The public nature of Twitter could narrow the areas in which one gets bang for the buck (the kinds of educational change or progress one might expect). Certainly, technological and instructional knowledge are important for administrators. Maybe administrators don’t need all that much online interaction about leadership issues; maybe Twitter helps edadmin connect, but the delicate or practice-related conversations happen offline (e.g., tweet-ups or school visits among tweeps). Also, some of my study participants mentioned the value of #satchat (which meets on Saturday mornings to discuss practical admin issues via Twitter)– and those tweets have yet to be accounted for. These are just a few examples of the things I’ll be teasing out and pondering over the next few months. Suggestions, questions, and feedback are appreciated greatly.

Advertisements

5 comments on “Could the public nature of Twitter HINDER professional learning?

  1. Carol Skyring
    November 30, 2012

    Writing for an audience is definitely an aspect to be considered. I look forward to exchanging ideas with you when I return to Oz & more stable internet connections. You can see what I’m researching at http://carolsdoctorate.pbworks.com/ Cheers

  2. vinnycho
    November 30, 2012

    Happy travels! I look forward to better connecting as well. My forthcoming Twitter article will draw upon the concepts of materiality and sociomateriality to highlight how ed scholars might better study what technologies do or don’t do. I presented preliminary findings this year at UCEA. http://www.vincentcho.com/cv–pubs.html

  3. Pingback: Technologies are what we make of them. | Datapulted

  4. Pingback: Tip: Want to connect to parents? Prioritize Facebook over Twitter | Datapulted

  5. Pingback: Classroom Blogging and Student Privacy | digitalliteracynh.org

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on November 30, 2012 by and tagged , .